Pages

Thursday, October 8, 2020

RAYA: Krishnadevaraya of Vijayanagara A Review

Srinivasa Reddy, a scholar of South Asian Literature trained in USA has tried his hand at writing history after a fairly successful run as a trasnslator. His earlier workGiver of Worn Garlands was an excellent translation of the putative work attributed to the Tuluva ruler Krishnadevaraya of Vijayanagara. The present work presents itself as a historically informed biography of the ruler but in reality it is a readable but badly researched work mixing legend, popular tradition and even cinematic renditions to create a pastice of historical narrative. Of course he has come with the proper credentials displayed prominently on the dusk jacket. It is certainly "engaging" but is it "exemplary" is a differnt question altogether.

Vijayangara history is complex in that it self consciously procalimed a template of Statecraft that was predicated upon the negation of the disruptions wrought by the onset or invasions of the turushka. In fact the trope of destroying the turushka appears even in the inscriptions of Krishnadeva Raya and to ignore the underlying political ideology animating Vijayanagara statecraft is merely a surrender to the kind of identity politics India has seen in the years follwing Independence. Turushka meant Turk and did not imply a religious identity at all and to shy away from this issue on the grounds that it may be offensive to present day sensibilities of political correctness is not merely being anachronistic by historically inaccurate.When Vijayanagara began its slow but steady march toward Empire it projected its raison d'tre as the Restoration of Worship in temples destroyed by the turushka. The raids of Kafur and the Tughlaqs had resulted in a virtual collapse of the moral order. The language of Apoclypse is deployed in an early Copper Plate Inscription: "When the sun. Prataparudra set, the world was enveloped in the turushka darkness".

Srinivasa Reddy begins his narrative biography of Krishnadevaraya with the famous Hampe Inscription which was trasnlated by Eugene Hultzsch in Epigraphia Indica Vol I. Generally recognised as a danasasana, issued on the occasion of his coronation the Inscription states in its 11th verse that Krishnadeva Raya connquered the Chera, Chola, the proud Pandyas, the brave Turushka, the Gajapathi king and others. This claim of conquest of the Gajapathi or for that matter even victory over the Turushka is merely rhetorical, a statement of intent rather than of accomplishemt an Krishdevaraya took control over the Empire upon the death of his half brother, Vira Narashimha in 1509 and there is no evidence that he had participated in any major campaign with his fater Narasa Nayaka. Again there is no hstorical evidence to suggest that Gandikota, Vinnukonda and Nagarajakonda were suggested as likely targets of Vijayanagar acquisition by Narasa Nayaka. Srinivas Reddy cannot resist the temptation of including an intersting myth, story fable even cinema  dialogues. Thus he accepts the story of Vidyaranya ad his association with Harihara and Bukka even though there is compelling evidence that this myth came to the fore only in the decades after 1565 as shown by Hermann Kulke. A historian will not allow an intersting story to structure his narrative.

The most impressive part of the book are the chapters dealing with the conflict with the Gajapathi rulers of Orissa. Reddy keeps harping on the "low caste" status of Krishnadevaraya. He calls him "dasi putra". There is absolutely no historical evidence to show that caste perceptions in any way influeced the conflict. Gajapathi, Narapathi and Ashwapathi remained the trypych around which the polity of the medieval South Indian empire revolved. And the Gajpathi king himself came fom a dynasty of usurpers and so would not have thow such caste laden invective against Krishnadevaraya. It appears tht identity politics of today and caste laden social sciences inflused with identity politics makes such outlandish interpretations not only possible but academically rspectable. The fact is that such labels were unknown in the Vijayanagara period.

Krishnadevara raya presided over an Empire that was linguistically diverse, complex in terms of religious and sectarian composition and the social structure of the Vijayanagara polity was certainly stratified. However caste was still not the deciding factor as the very diversity of the Great Captains, the amaranayankara-s. demonstrates. Only one Historian has attempted a prosopographical study of Nayakas. Krishnadevaraya bore the biruda, Hindu raya Sutrranna or Sultan of HinduKings a title which underscores the tremendous influence of the Islamic political formations of the Deccan.

The book under review is certainly interesting. But its claim to be History can be contested.
 

Thursday, January 16, 2020

The History Men: Jadunath Sarkar Sardesai, Raghubir Sinh and the Quest for India's Past by T C A Raghavan

Dr T C A Raghavan, a noted diplomat, historian and public intelelctual has written an outstanding book which covers the territory upon which Dipesh Chakravarthy has grazed in his Calling of History. Charkavarthy was concerned only with the writings of Sir Jadunath Sarkar, Ragavan has traversed a much larger chunk of Historiography. He has situated his examination of the three historians whose work he has analysed in great depth, at the intersection of their individual lives, their collaboration in the pursuit of historical documents and the deep personal bonds of friendship that bound them. Their quest for India's past took them to remote villages, towns and cities all over North India and Mahrashtra and thye uncovered significant troves of historical material which were carefully edited and published. All three of the scholars were pioneers in that they were historians who had to locate, collate and edit the documents on which their histories were based. And for the Maharatha Period and the Post Mughal Era this meant a mastery over a number of scripts and languages: Mahrathi, Persian, Arabic, French, Dutch and Portuguese. The three historians collaborated with each other as Dr Raghavan has shown in the most intensnse and academically fruitful manner. It is interesting to learn that Sir Jadunath Sarkar's reconstruction of the Battle of Panipat, 1761 was based on a contemporary record. The Hafta Anjuman a post Mughal history was located and used by Sarkar in his Fall of the Mughal Empire.

The History Men is an important work of historiography as it deals with the intellectual climate in which Indians began to explore their past. This quest was particularly difficult as it coincided with two very huge popular movements: the Freedom Movement and the Partition Movement, both at times collaborating and at times confronting each other. Politically the times were charged with the high voltage current of identity politics, the Moslem and Hindu one aimed at carving a holemand for the Muslims and the other aimed at preserving the unity and integrity of India as a nation and Civilization. Sir Jadunath Sarkar himelf was a victim of the Partion Movement as his eledest son was killed in the riots. And as Raghavan points out he did not recover from this tragedy. The substantial work of Sir Jadunath revolved around Aurangazeb and his reign. His five volume History of Aurangazeb was based on the original letters and Court Documents which were located in Jaipur, Gwalior and other places. Sarkar used the court documents judicially and his account of the rise of the Maharathas as the most powerful challengers to the hegemony of the Mughals was essentially an analysis of Mahratha documents. The collaboration with G S Sardesai was important as Sarkar though conversant with Modi had his transcripts of the Mahrati documents checked by Sardesai.

In his Shivaji and His Times, Sarkar provided a balanced and nuanced account of Sivaji but the Poona Scholars associated with the Ithihasa Samshodaka Mandala like Rajwade were quite hostile to the work. Raghavan expalins the hostility as stemming from the intrusion of a Bengali in Mahrashtra and its history at a time when the cult around Shivaji was becoming the defining element in the identity of Maharashtrians. There is also the growing assertion of a caste identity during this time and Shivaji and his legacy were deeply contested. Rughubir Sinh, the scion of the Sitamau Princely State located in Malwa wrote his D Phil thesis on Malwa in Transition a work which was much appreciated by Sarkar. Later Raghubir Sinh became a memmber of the Lok Sabha and served two terms and established a Research Institute at Sitmau.

Raghavan has done a splendid job in ressurecting the memory and contribution of these early pioneers of Indian Historiography. One of the unfortunate developments of post Independence Era was the appropriation of Indian History by an ideologically committed group of historians, some would even say cabal of histry peddlers, who with the patronage of the Indian State drove these pioneers into obvlivion. Their pamphlet Communalism and the Writing of Indian History published by the Peoples' Publishing House became the manifesto for a kind of History thatn pitted Historians into hostile camps. Anyone disagreeing with the High Priets of the New Creed was  "Communal" :\"Reactionary" "Anti Modern" etc. The climate of free and dispassionate reconstruction of the past was vitiated by the personality clash betwee the pioneers like Sarkar, Sardesai, Majumdhar, Nilakanta Sastri, H C Ray chowdhury and others with Mohammad Habib and later his son and successor, Irfan Habib. That this clash has not ended is made amply clear in the recent public brawl in which Irfan Habib prevented the Governor of Kerala from continuing with his Speech. An ugly episode which would have been unthinkable in the civilzed days of Sarkar and friends

Monday, November 18, 2019

SOUTH INDIAN INSCRIPTIONS VOL XXXVIII (1912) Collection

The Archaeological Survey of India needs to be congratulated for bringing out this excellent collection of medeival South Indian Inscriptions. The editor Dr S Swaminathan has done a conmendable job in collecting, collating and reconstructing the texts of 636 inscriptions collected during the year 1912. The publication of an SII volume is keenly anticipated by historians as each one is a treasure house of information in that a society that did not have the intellectual ability to record its owen past is always at a disadvantage. Fortunately Inscriptions come in handy and provide a wealth of information about historical conditions prevailing in the medieval period.

The volume under consideration consists essentially of Chola and Vijayanagara Inscriptions and these are distributed thoughout the 3 major states of South India with Tamil Nadu taking the vast majority of the Inscriptions. When Eugene Hultzch began the Seies way back in 1887 few would have imafgined that more that a 125 years later the series will still be around and going from strength to strength. Dr Swaminathan himself has edited 3 volumes in this series and that marks a significant contribution to South Indian history. All the conventions of epigraphic publication are followed: the text is given is as complete a manner as possible with * denoting the conjectural reading. The text is user friendly and the introcuction summarises the inscription adequately. Some early Pallava inscriptions are useful for calculating the rate of interest on gold deposited in a temple treasury. Interesting sidelight on temple wealth and its moral status in contemporary society is provided by an example from Trivuvorriyur Temple in which a sum of 811 kalunju of gold was levied as fine from those who misappropriated temple property. This is a far cry from today when Temple under Government Departments are being systematically robbed of their wealth. In Triruchendur Temple the entire Jewelry of the temple was replace with fake ornaments. The dravidianist political culture in Tamil Nadu today is spelling a death knell to the culture and intellectual vitality of the Tamil country.

A detailed study of the Tiruvorryur Temple is now possible as a cirect onsequence of the publication under review. As a padal perra stalam, this temple enjoyed considerable patronage under the early Cholas and under Parantaka I (905-955) this temple acquired royal stature due to the association of Velan Kumaran, a military officer who was defeated in the Battle of Takkolam. Another unique aspect of this volume is the collection from Devikapuram, North Arcot District. The earliest mention of Iswara Nayaka of the Tuluva line and the father of Narasa Nayaka occurs in one of the inscriptions here.

The volume is a valuable addition to the growing Corpus of Inscriptions dealing with an important period of South Indian past.

Tuesday, July 23, 2019

Vyasa Tirtha, the Vijayanagara Empire and contemporary India: The Destruction of the Brundavan at Hampi

Seldom does a Historian get to write about events that impact his personal life, beliefs and question the assumptions of his craft. In my life the destruction of the Brundavan of the great Madhava Saint and philosopher, Vyasa Tirtha by an act of calculated vandalism on the night of 15th July was just that moment. As a Madhva whose Ph D was on Vijayanagara History and most of whose reseach in some way has centered on Vijayanagara Empire, this bog among other things stand testement, I was deeply hurt by the images I saw. The vandalism of the Brundavan of Vyasa thirtha has been blamed on "treasure hunters". I do not think that this is a plausible hypothesis as everyone knows that a Brundavan does not contain any tresure except the mortal remains of the person whose smrithi is remembered by way of aradhana. which is performed every year inmemory of the Saint . This being the case blaming "tresasure hunters" seems to be an easy way to avoid raising valid questions. In Karnataka there is a lot of debate over the status of Lingayats. The Vokkaliga dominated H D Kumarawsamy Government is tottering and the state is in the grip of political uncertainity. This factor needs to be considered while dealing with the issue at hand. Identity politics has made it possible for every fractured identity group to become vocal and start demanding a peice of the electoral pie. The success of the BJP in the May 2019 General elections in which the BJP won 27 of 29 seats and the Vokkaliga leader, Deve Gowda himself losing the elections shows that there is a lot of political churning going on in Karnataka. I think that the politcal crisis in Karnataka has to be taken into consideration while addressing this issue.


The vadndalism of the Brundavan is shown in the photograph on the left. The Brundavan which is essentially granite slabs arranged is vertical slabs around the place where the mortal remains of the saint are interred. In the case of Vyasa thirtha he was interred in the island in the middle of the Tungabhadra River called, Nav Brundavan as nine such edifices are located there. The sanctity of the place is attedted by the songs of Purandara Dasa Knaka Dasa and others who spoke with bhakthi about the sacraltity of the place. Madhvas do not worship relics like the Roman Catholics venerate relics of saints. The brudavana is only a Site of Memory (lieu de Memoire).

The destruction of a sacred site suggets a calculated attempt at stirring up identity politics and humiliating a community that venerates saints like Vyasa, Jayatirta and Narahari Tirtha




The crime must have taken a good deal of the night and the criminalshad come equipped with elctrical torches and mechanized tools to pry open the stone slabs. When the site of the crime was examined the next day vital clues were found which enabled the Karnataka Police to apprehend 5 criminals from the neighbouring state of Andhra Pradesh, Let us see if the state is able to prosecute the case successfully in the Courts.

Vyasa tiirtha (AD 1477-1539) is one of the most celebrared figures in Madhva Dvaita Philosophy. He was well connected to the court of Saluva Narashima when he was ruling over Chandragiri Rajyam, the area around the Tirupathi region. When Saluva Narashima seized the throne of Vijayanagara in 1485, Vyasatirtha moved to Vijayanagara and was close to the Saluvas during the critical period of the Saluva Usurpation. After the death of Immadi Narashima the son of the Saluva king, the general Narasa Nayaka seized the throne or as the Inscriptions of the period put it gaciously accepted the Lion Throne. Narasa Nayaka was succeeded by his son, Krishnadeva raya (AD 1509-1529) and it was during the reign of the Tuluvas that Vyasatirtha became a very powerful personality. The dominance of Sri Vaishnavism in general and the Madhava faith, in particular during the Tuluva period needs to be examined in some detail. Both the Mutts of Uttaradi and Vyasa have Copper Plate Inscrioption dating to this period and unfortunately no attempt has been made to make these valuable records available to the Historians working on Vijayanagara.

Vyasatirtha was the clebrated author of the Tatparya Chandhrika and Taraka tandava. Being a scholar of Sanskrit and one with a fierce grasp over the textual tradition or Sampradaya, Vyasa tirtha had no problem in defeating the importatant exponents of advaita as shown by Somannatha in his Vyasa Yoga Carita. The closeness or proximity to the throne is also expalined by the fact that during the famous Conjunction of Nine Planets that took place in 1524 Vyasa tirtha occupied the throne thereby averting danger, as per the hagiographical tradition, to the Vijayanagara throne. It must be said that excessive partonage give to the Sri Vaishnava Religion led ultimately to the collapse of the empire.

The destruction of the Brundavan is a despicable act and must be condemend.


Tuesday, July 16, 2019

"The Empire of Apostles" A review of Empire Jesuit Evagalism and Imperialism

The Empire of Apostles: Religion, Accommodario and the Imagination of Empire
in Early Modern Brazil and India
Ananya Chakravati
New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2019.

Post colonial litereary theory informed approaches to History make interesting reading and the imaginative leap from one corner of the world to another is breathtaking in its audacity as it is misinformed by its methodological and theoretical principles. The Empire of Apostles falls squarely in this category. It is essentailly an intellectual history of two Jesuit missions to India and Brazil: St. Francis Xavier in the case of India and Manuel de No'brega in the case of Brazil. What the author fails to understand that the expansion of the Roman Catholic Chrurch and other manifestations of Chruch based religiosities was accompanied by a horrendous display, theratrical at times, viciously exemplary on most ocassions, of violence against the indigenous people who had no real means of defending theselves against white imperialism. In his recent book, Civilizing Torture: An American Tradition, Fitzhugh Brundage has taken up precisely this issue and has provided an excellent method to pry open the suppressed histories of Rape, Genocide, Violence and Oppression that white impreialism brought in its wake. Perhaps there is no academic market for honest History anynore and we are left with the work I am reviewing because I paid my hard earned money to buy this book.

The Pope facilitated the division of the world between the Spanish and the Portuguese thrones and the Crown of Portugal was given the right of paodradoa to appont priests in both the Portuguese territories of Brazil and India. The Jesuits right from the time of St. Ignitius Loyola advocated a strong and mutually benefitting alliance with the Throne and this enables St Francis Xavier to come to India from where he went to the Spice Islands and Japan. Manuel de No'brega was sent to Brazil. In South America the Catholic Church along with the Spanish and Portuguese settlers unleashed a genocidal war against the First Citizens and the ideological justification for such horrendous dipplays of brutality was provided by the Churuch which said that it aims at Converting the people of the land so that their souls are saved. Church and State marched hand in had destroying the indigenous culture of South America. The Jesuits on a few ocassions tried to blunt the violent sword but their very presence in the theatres of war legitimised the venture. The process by which the Jesuits negotiated with the local indigenpous culture is termed as Accommodatio, cultural undersytanding tolerance or even compromise. In India Jesuits pioneered this art and Robert de Nobili and Beschi even appeared in Native garb to make people beleive that they have assimilated local culture. It goes without saying that such shenanigans did hoodwink the people.

In India, St Francis Xavier was the one responsible for bringing the dreeaded papal Instrument of Inquisition to Goa and until 1807 when the auto da faye was ended under English East India Company pressure, the Inqusition had claimed around 35,000 lives: People burnt at the stake for possessing Hindu icons or practicing the forbidden faith or keeping prayer books.  The Goa Archives contain a small fraction of the Inquisition records. Even Vijayanagara Empire did not interfere with the Portuguese cultural practices in their relic state.

The book is certainly not a contribution either to the history of India, Brazil or of the Poertuguese empire. 

Monday, March 25, 2019

Flight of Deities and the Rebirth of Temples:Episodes for Indian History

Flight of Deities and Rebirth of Temples: Episodes in Indian History
Meenakshi Jain
New Delhi Aryan Books International, 2019

One of the most tragic and neglected aspects of medieval historiography of India is the fate of Hindu, Buddhist and Jaina Temples. Sita Ram Goel several years back addressed this issue and indicted the medieval rulers for following a political strategy of destroying Hindu places of worship and the systematic destruction od Hindu, Buddhist and Jaina centres of worship and pilgrimage, he argues was party of the political and imperial ideology stemming from Islamic ideas of conquest and conversion of Darul Harb into Dar ul Islam, from Land of War to Land of Islam. Hence the destruction of Indian religious institutions cannot be view in isolation of the ideological underpinning of the Turkish, Afghan and Mughal rule over India. This interpretation was, of course, attacked by a whole host of historians from Alighr Muslim University, Delhi University and of course, Jawaharlal Nehru University. Is this interpretation a "communal" one or, even if not politically correct have the weight of historical evidence behind it.


The deliberate underplaying of Moslem vandalism in parts of India which were conquered may have been a political necessity in the years after Partition when Hindu Moslem tension were high and it was prudent to avoid contentious and identity laden issues. However, 70 years after Independence if the same platitudes are trotted out, it becomes necessary to re investigate the issue and assess the question on the basis of evidence. In short, the time for political correctness is past and it is time to seize the historical moment even as it disintegrates before our very eyes. Meenakshi Jain has produced a scholarly and eminently well researched work on this question. She starts where Sita Ram Goel left and her work is a fitting riposte to all those historians who live in a state of denial about the tragedy the befell India. After reading the work under review it will not be possible for anyone either to deny the political underpinning of the reign of vandalism unleashed against Hindu and other Indian religious structures or belittle the cultural and civilizational chaos it engendered.

One argument that white scholars like Richard Davis and Richard Eaton are quick to advance is that the Turks, Afghans and Mughals did not indulge in any sort of vandalism and destruction which Indian rulers had not done in the past. This line of argument is absolutely incorrect as there is not a single instance in which a ruler of India be he Jain, Buddhist as Harsha or Hindu/Shiva like Rajendra subjected the images captured for religious sites and appropriated for relocation in their own imperial repertoire ever showed an attitude of anything less than reverence. Thus when Krishnadevaraya captured Udayagiri and acquired the green granite Balarama image, he had a Krishna temple constructed in his capital, Vijayanagara, and had the image installed with reverence. Similarly, when Rajendra Chola brought back the image of Durga from the territories of the Western Chalukyas he had it enshrined in his new capital, Gangaikonda cholapuram. Such example can be multiplied. However after the Islamic conquest, temples were detroyed and the sanctity of the temple violated by the shedding of blood and was usually accompanied, as was the case with the Vaishnava Temple of Srirangam, a whole sale massacre of the temple priests. To deny the cold facts of history, recorded in the medieval Chronicles is to deny the very validity of History as a field of study.

Meenakshi Jain has produced a fine piece of historical research. It is true that the academic climate for a free investigation of India's tangled and tortured past has opened up only recently and I fervently hope that historians of India cease to function as servitors of political parties, start researching the past without fear or favour.

Tuesday, December 4, 2018

The Coinage and History of Vijayanagara A Review

The Coinage and History of Vijayanagara Empire
M Girirajapathi
Bangalore, 2009

The monetary history of the Vijayanagara Empire is still rather obscure. Indian Archaeology A Review records the discovery of more than 307 coin hoards between 1954 and 2001. While certainly not an numerous both in provenance and distribution as Sultanate or Mughal coin hoards, Vijayanagara monetary history does present interesting questions of its own. One aspect that has come to the fore is the interlinking between Bahamani coinage and currency system with the Vijayanagara currency. Partly this is reflected in  majority of the coin deposits which are found mixed with sultante minted coins. Phillip Wagoner has studied this feature in a recent article published in the
Coinage and History of Vijayanagara
Indian Economic and Social History Review vol 51, 4 (2014) pp 457-480.

The book under review is a catalog of a few private numismatic collections. It makes no attempt at analysis and even the basic numismatic data is given in a rather loose manner. The provenance of the coins is not documented and the relative chronology between various coin types is not addressed. On the whole this is a very disappointing work.

The Bahamani historian Firishta has given a great deal of information about the relative value of different currencies circulating in  the region. In spite of efforts undertaken by Sultan Muhammad Shah I (1358-75) to discourage the circulation and exchange of Vijayanagara gold coins in Bahamani territories, little change was felt on the ground. The value of the Pratap and Hon need to be worked out. The reasons for the complete absence of silver coins in Vijayanagara need to be investigated. The metrology of Vijayanagara coinage needs to be determined.

This work is printed on expensive art paper but it avoids discussing any issue of importance.